What are your Top 4 favourite tabletop RPG settings that were designed specifically for #TTRPGs (so no Warhammer, Star Wars, Conan, etc.)?
Here are mine
Hyperborea - Clark Ashton Smith, REH and HPL inspired weird fantasy.
2300AD - 300 years post Twilight War the nations of earth colonize the stars and find some things very unexpected.
Aeon Trinity - psychics battling mutated supers while making Earth a better place.
Gamma World - Gonzo post apoc
@spezbaby technically that would cut out Glorantha and Tekumel (*), my C&S Campaigns, mostly, being historical, apart from my first, even Traveller's Imperium has stuff in from other works
Thrankhuria - my first C&S campaign, a mix of Conan and Elric
Saurians - C&S 1 intelligent Dino setting
Ravenloft - reworked a fair bit into my games
Middle World - my current Essence campaign, based on 600BCE Western Asia
(*) Tarnished as it may be
Spelljammer - What if Newton was completely wrong and Space is full of swashbuckling adventure, tinker gnomes and insufferable elves?
Shadowrun - cyberpunk/magic fusion with local sourcebooks, often written by actual Shadowrun fans from that country/area
Planescape - weird fantasy setting fleshing out the wheel-cosmology proposed by TSR earlier.
Forgotten Realms - high fantasy, might seem vanilla nowadays but it’s the first I ever played and we had years of fun there.
@spezbaby
#TrophyLoom
#DarkSun
#Ravenloft
The implied setting of #MothershipRPG
@spezbaby Talislanta
Aberrant
Vampire: The Requiem
Rifts
Duskvol, Glorantha, Night City, Shadowrun
@spezbaby@dice.camp oh I still have Version of Aeon wenn it was called trinity
But unfortunately never played it.
@qeqar Trinity came second. Aeon was the first name until MTV (I believe) got involved.
We played a bunch for a while in the 90s.
I remember it, the setting and the spaceships fondly.
@spezbaby@dice.camp ok too long ago. Then I have the Aeon version too
I only remember that I have the first version and that the setting has PSY power.
Empire of the Petal Throne
Metamorphosis Alpha
Runequest
Shadowrun
@spezbaby
The following i always thought were interestingly thought out:
Dark Sun - Especially early 1st edition presented a D&D-type setting ravaged by misuse of magic.
Gamma World - Especially 4th and 7th editions, even though they present essentially different settings.
Dragonstar - Probably my favorite take on D&D + space travel
Classic World of Darkness - Especially Changeling and Mage
@spezbaby
Gamma World would be one of them.
Spelljammer - D&D in space
Dragonstar - D&D in the future with spaceships
Dragonmech - D&D with mechs
I guess futuristic D&D is my preference. #GammaWorld #Spelljammer #Dragonstar #Dragonmech
@spezbaby@dice.camp
Does Forgotten Realms count? It started as Greenwood's unpublished short stories in the early '60s, then stuff he published in Dragon Magazine, and all the published fiction came after it was an official D&D setting.
That's my favorite if it counts.
@Hawkwinter I would say yes.
@spezbaby@dice.camp
Then, [Pre-4e/1385DR] Forgotten Realms it is. It's so developed; I love the novels; I grew up with the AD&D comic books about Kyriani Agrivar in the early '90s; I love the fiction tying back into the gamebooks.
The 2e gamebooks are more thorough, but some of the 3e ones are good compilations. The 3e FRCS is great for that.
I thought the 3e FaP religion book was a bad compilation of the four 2e religion books though - overly focused on the personalities and statblocks of the gods themselves and not focused enough on the churches.
Grand History is a fun book for the shelf, but I don't think I've ever used it for an actual game rather than the sources it draws most of its information from.
But the 3e FRCS was /solid/.
@Hawkwinter @spezbaby
While I would never begrudge or belittle anyone their love of the setting, I have very mixed feelings about the Forgotten Realms.
On one hand:
With a name like "Forgotten Realms", as a kid, I though it would largely involve exploring mysterious, previously lost areas. But is almost entirely NOT about that. In fact most regions are almost OVERdefined.
1/x
@Hawkwinter @spezbaby
The setting seemed to suffer from "everything and the kitchen sink" content bloat. Like so full of crazy things, each more powerful than the last, every shenanigan wilder than the one before, its hard for me to imagine any kind of normal life existing there in contrast.
I've liked little of the fiction i read. Most seemed rambling and involved characters I don't really connect with. Even things people point out as "the good stuff" left me indifferent.
2/x
@Hawkwinter @spezbaby
But, on the other hand, after hearing the podcast linked below, I had to admire:
The history of how the Forgotten Realms came about, how Ed gradually expanded on it over time beginning from childhood interest in stories.
Also, Greenwood's efforts to make the setting accessible to fans have gone above and beyond.
http://plotpoints.libsyn.com/ed-greenwood-sold-the-forgotten-realms-for-5000-ep-174
3/3
@PTR_K@dice.camp @spezbaby@dice.camp
I though it would largely involve exploring mysterious, previously lost areas. But is almost entirely NOT about thatYeah, the 'forgotten' is that it's an alternate world connected to earth, and we earth-humans forgot about it.
In fact most regions are almost OVERdefined.Hmm. I suspect that's a matter of taste. For me OVERdefined would be "has more information than Wikipedia + local government sites + google maps has about the real world."
The setting seemed to suffer from "everything and the kitchen sink" content bloat. Like so full of crazy things, each more powerful than the last, every shenanigan wilder than the one before, its hard for me to imagine any kind of normal life existing there in contrast.It's definitely not "medieval or renaissance europe with a few changes" - I think it's closest analogue is a renaissance magic-based Marvel Earth 616 full of Mutants and wizards and Monsters. There's pretty frequent mentions of regular citizens having wondrous items like Mickey mouse's house-cleaning broom, 'elfgates' spelljammers, etc. I think it's a renaisance magic-fantasy superhero setting. But I can appreciate not everyon is into that. Sometimes it's not what I'm in the mood for either, and I want something closer to GURPS low tech + GURPS fantasy, or one of the d100 /BRP / Runequest mythic earth settings.
I've liked little of the fiction i read. Most seemed rambling and involved characters I don't really connect with. Even things people point out as "the good stuff" left me indifferent.That's unfortunate, but fair enough. I fail to connect with lots of more popular things. I could not at all, ever get into Warhammer 30k / 40k, for instance. The more I hear about the setting, the more I hate it.
But, on the other hand, after hearing the podcast linked below, I had to admire: The history of how the Forgotten Realms came about, how Ed gradually expanded on it over time beginning from childhood interest in stories.It's impressive the amount of care that went into how he curated the thing, often in spite of corporate meddling.
Also, Greenwood's efforts to make the setting accessible to fans have gone above and beyond.I've been really liking his Youtube interview show, and when my finances are a bit better I want to back his Patreon to see the extended interviews and whatever else he puts up there.
http://plotpoints.libsyn.com/ed-greenwood-sold-the-forgotten-realms-for-5000-ep-174